MacBook Pro frustration

Well, Apple, well,

beginning of December 2006 I thought it would be nice to have a new Laptop to play around with some photo software and get a speed bump for my Al PB 4G bought end September 2003. A MacBook Pro Core 2 Duo seemed to be a decent option. I also hoped that Apple had improved their quality management and I would not go through the nasty experience I had with my Al PB to have the screen replaced 5 times until it deemed ok (you might remember the white spots and the uneven illumination issues Apple had with their first 15" Aluminum PowerBooks). The fact that Apple was really fair with their replacement and repair policy mitigated the issues, however it was still annoying to spent hours in discussions with Apple Care reps and wait for a repair and return.

I ordered my 2.33 GHz MBP C2D 160 gig CTO matte on Dec-01-2006. It was promised to arrive Dec-21-2006, therefore I was very pleased to receive 4 days later the note, that it will ship Dec-05-2001. After TNT trying to hunt me down for some days hold it in my hands Dec-12-2006.

I booted up the nice box, but immediately recognized that something is strange with the screen. It was not obvious for me the first time. After working with it for half a day, I recognized stressed eyes. Further examinations of the screen showed the following issues:

  • very small horizontal viewing angle, moving the head up and down for some centimeters already resulted in color shifts on the lower or upper area of the screen
  • a strange kind of glitter all over the screen (looked like dust, even though the screen was clean)
  • uneven illumination (especially a bright stripe on the bottom of the screen)
  • minor, but still annoying, a red stuck pixel and some more Grey stuck pixels


MacBook Pro boxes piling up


OK, OK, Apple, still being positive I called Apple care and they offered me a replacement which might arrive prior to Christmas, evtl. shortly after Christmas. After signing a waiver form (to make sure that I don't keep two MacBooks) I could keep my first one. Some google research disclosed that I am not alone with this issue: It looked like the the supplier has manufacturing problem. My display (open Display Preferences, click Color, click Open Profile, scroll down to list item 13) has the following parameters
  • Display Manufacturer #00000610
  • Display Model #00009C57
Today (03-Jan-2007) version two arrived. After quickly booting it up I saw that it had the exact same issues. The stuck pixels are gone, but the viewing angle is still bad. Display Model is again #00009C57. After an other hour talking to (very supportive) Apple agents I am now waiting for version three.


Lets see, if this one gets better. If not, I might stick with my PB 4G 15" and hope for better Quality management @ Apple.
-gramels

This entry was posted by admin on Wednesday, January 3. 2007 at 19:43. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own blog.
Defined tags for this entry: , , , , ,
Related entries by tags:
[iUsability-Pwned] critical iPhone 3.0 bug/feature
iPhone backup & timemachine
CCC camp07 dog rules
Samsung SGH-X820 (no) iSync workaround
Rimowa & [die Räder/ the wheels]

Trackbacks

Trackback specific URI for this entry
  1. MacBook Pro frustration [updated]

    Well, Apple, well,the products look cool (and i have to admit the iPhone might get me too), OS X is best in terms of usability, but the issues with the quality of the Displays of your flagship laptop are a killer.MacBook Pro frustration - gramels blogI

    Weblog: gramels blog
    Tracked: Feb 04, 09:46
  2. MacBook Pro (Display) frustration [not allone]

    Adam brought his frustration about Apple Displays to the next step by providing a video:http://adam.lumanation.com/archives/134and made me aware of it in his comment in my blogI wrote about that twice here:http://gramelspacher.ch/blog/index.php?/archive

    Weblog: gramels blog
    Tracked: Feb 11, 12:03

Comments

Display comments as (Linear | Threaded)

    No comments


Add Comment


HTML-Tags will be converted to Entities.
E-Mail addresses will not be displayed and will only be used for E-Mail notifications

To prevent automated Bots from commentspamming, please enter the string you see in the image below in the appropriate input box. Your comment will only be submitted if the strings match. Please ensure that your browser supports and accepts cookies, or your comment cannot be verified correctly.
CAPTCHA

Standard emoticons like :-) and ;-) are converted to images.